As the economic growth, our lives become more convenient. However it
also causes a lot of problem such as murder, theft and so on. How can we solve
the problem if it doesn’t settle by discussion? In that case we often talk with
law. If we do not have law, our lives are always dangerous and weak people become
weaker. Thus we can’t talk our safety lives without law, but it’s too difficult
for everyone to remember. So we often talk in court and judge by legal people
such as judge, lawyer, prosecutor and so on. Lately, it often bought in a
verdict by jury in Britain because of reflection of public opinions. However
there are many problems of jury system. So I think trial by jury should be
abolished in Britain and there are three points for why it is better to do so.
First, I’ll talk about expense and time of jury trial. If you were
elected to be a jury in Britain, you can claim for travel, lunch, refreshments,
loss of earnings and other expenses.
Maximum daily amount you can claim will change by length of jury service
and time spent each day. For example, if you have a child, you can claim for
the cost of employing a child-minder or carer. All of expenses may be large
amount. Of course, the expenses of jury is not the only expenses in court. They
also have to pay for judge, lawyer, prosecutor and so on. So if there is a jury
system, they should pay all of them. We talked about expenses, now how about
time? As you can imagine it needs a lot of time. Finding a jury for a trial
already append much money and to be jury also spend much money. Don’t you think
it is waste of money? All of expenses and time in jury system far more than
their worth.
Second, each person’s opinion is different. It is clear in deta. For
instance, young women are strict with defendant, but on the other hand, old men
are strict. If it occurs, it may influences a verdict. The differences old men
are petty with defendant so that even it is same case, young women may brought
a heavier verdict, but old men may brought a lighter one. In another example,
it may be different from the prejudice. There is an opinion about “Prejudiced
Jurors” from “The Disadvantages of the Jury System” in the site of eHow. It
says “A jury trial
presents a disadvantage for defendants when prejudice is an issue. Local biases
and prejudices influence the outcome of many trials. The jurors disregard logic
presented by a judge or defense lawyer, because of past experiences or moral
sentiment. Prejudiced jurors have unjustly convicted innocent defendants. Stereotyping
and racial profiling contribute to miscarriage of justice in some case. (http://www.ehow.com/info_8163035_disadvantages-jury-system.html
) ” Therefore the verdict may differed by ages, gender and thought. All of
juries are random elected.
Last of all, most juries are lack of legal knowledge and
intelligence. As I told you at the beginning, it needs a lot of knowledge of
law. However most people have little or no training in matters of law. In my
case, I learned about law in junior high school or high school, but we don’t
learn about detail. Of course I can’t remember all I learned in school. I only
remember system in court and I think most people are same with me. Furthermore
the person who lacks intelligence is increased. “The Disadvantages of the Jury
System” also says “Most
jury members don't completely understand the laws they must follow. Scientific
evidence is difficult for some jurors to comprehend. The average juror does not
understand complex evidence in some trials regardless of his qualifications. It
is difficult for jurors to assess the reliability of witnesses or evidence.
Many jurors in civil trials involving financial matters do not grasp the
evidence presented.” Therefore the lack of knowledge and
intelligence may allow prosecutor to convince or persuade juries to believe
their opinion easily. A trial always influences many people’s lives. Isn’t it
dangerous for juries to brought in a verdict?
It is important to listen to the opinions of ordinary people and
many people will learn about law. The jury system may be a big chance for
everyone to think about judge. And the experience of being a jury must be a
valuable experience. So I know there are also many advantages. However as I
told you, expense of jury trial, different opinion of each person and lack of
legal knowledge will be the bigger problems. Of course not only these points
are disadvantages but also much more problems are in the jury system. Those
disadvantages may outweigh advantages. Do you still think it is worth to hold the
jury system?
References
Sixth form law
The Disadvantages of Jury System
Jury service
Jury service payments: A Fair Trial
0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿